MC6 Round 1 Results - Mloob

 
"Mloob"
(m6r-mlob.zip)

by

Josh Dj Phil Harmonic
(Dj Phil Harmonic)


This song competed in the rookie division of Music Contest 6, where it ranked in block 5.

Judge: Szekely ,Saar

This song is original, nice and pretty good. It could have been much better if more chords were added, and not only one played over and over again. The chords themself are nicely played (channels 10-11). The solo is also interesting in the beginning, but loses interest after a few patterns, mabyve vecause he is played on only one chord, and doesn't develps. The end doesn't give a feel of a real end, and is too sudden for a song that beginned with a slight "fade-in" of instruments. yours: Vel.

Judge: Edmondson ,David

I wasn't too crazy about this song. It reused the same drum beat throughout the entire song (from beginning to end). There was some panning, but there wasn't much point to most of the tone floats. The solo (bagpipe, maybe?) wasn't loud enough, and had kind of annoying sound to it. The vibes used near the end were very repetitive, and it was obvious that there wasn't much work put into the ending. In fact, the only things I can say for this is that the samples, for the most part, were clear, and it started out fine, but it just didn't have enough substance to give it a higher score.

Judge: Grandpre ,Dan

I like the delayed-flam-ish groove this starts out with quite a bit-- then i dont know why that horrible waveform lead sound comes in.. its completely inappropriate and the sample is also flat.. Not much else happens other than that this 'lead' goes on and on- the once cool groove really has nothing to back it up now and it just starts to trudge on and on.... There isn't really much else to say since nothing else happens... disappointing tune..

Judge: Wu ,Sherman

Nice electric sound in this track. The arabic sounding scales used in this song were OK, but nothing too new. Yet, the song managed to keep my interest. Good use of stereo. Unfortunately, this song seemed to just go in circles. Give it some direction - more developement.

Judge: Hampton ,Chris

Groovy tune. Nice bassline.. "Original" panning on those drums (left.. right.. etc :D) I don't know about that chip lead. It fits.. But I don't know about it. This song is pretty groovy though.. I can tell you that. Is that drumloop off a little bit? Oh well. The only thing that gets me is the fact that you had such a cool groove going but you don't really do anything with the song.. It seems like a long intro that doesn't go anywhere :D ... My suggestion? Hmm.. Work in some other chords, or work with those chords to make a melody.. Add a chorus? Do odd things to it.

Judge: Noel ,Elliott

Alittle repetitive but some interesting harmonies. Clean-sounding.