MC6 Round 1 Results - Gt Aisle 90 Dub War |
"Gt Aisle 90 Dub War" (m6v-gt90.zip) by
Calvin PsySal
This song competed in the veteran division of Music Contest 6, where it ranked in block 6. |
Judge: Sega ,Andrew This song sounds like a cross between 70's funk, and old Amiga four-channel chiptunes. The samples are unimpressive chip leads, with no modulation or arpeggio or anything to liven them up. I am convinced large amounts of track data were entered with the 'random note' method. There are a few patterns in the middle where it sounds like its actually coming together (7-8), but unfortunately it's a letdown. The structure of the piece is confusing and incoherent. Overall, a mess. |
Judge: Raitio ,Samuel Great song name! There is happening a lot through this song, and very skillfully tracked things they are, but where is the common goal? The song reminds me of a jam session where a lot of good ideas come up, but they need a lot of work and organizing to become a song. |
Judge: Szmajda ,Joshua May I ask what you were thinking? This is dissonant, poorly tracked, ill fit material. It seems to belong in the rookie category. The samples are probably picked for a reason, but it's lost in the cacophany. your bass lines interflict with each other, and don't fit the chords you seemingly randomly throw together. Your progrssions are random, and the only thing this song has going for it is maybe some rythmical idea. Not even that, though. |
Judge: Tanase ,Adrian Weird style, strange tune. Drums very poorly chosen. The song is worked pretty good, but the samples don't match the style. .... |
Judge: Sipe ,Conor Wow...what can I say about this song? Only one work really comes to mind...jumbled. The intro is a crazy assortment of effects that only vaguely sound like they go together. However, I did like the bassline towards the beginning of the song. No coherent theme is held to over the course of the song, and as a result, it is just too broken up. Nice effects and samples, but ya gotta have a more coherent sound. |