MC6 Round 1 Results - Leaves Ii |
"Leaves Ii" (m6v-leav.zip) by
Bart Bart
This song competed in the veteran division of Music Contest 6, where it ranked in block 4. |
Judge: Soboll ,Claudio Leaves 2: ambient and futuristic. good beginning with a nice synth effect. it has no real melody though the structure is never annoying. songlength and samples are ok except a cymbal that sounds too 'rough' for me. i cant call this one awesome but a nice and good work. a lead-instrument like a guitar would fit perfectly. the mood is very spacey and relaxing. 60 |
Judge: Kemp ,Brian DAMN! I am impressed! For only one melodic sample, this is incredible--I don't really have that many problems with it. I could piss and bitch about the sample quality, but then again, I would be simply nit-picking because the samples are of great quality. The rhythm is synchopated enough, repetition is kept to acceptable levels...the effects are well-placed...the mood's there... I don't see any problems with this song...sorry to be such a horrible? critic :P I think this song deserves 3 digits. |
Judge: Basic ,Predrag Pretty Good, can't really find any technical flaws in this one. The music however doesn't really have togetherness in a song type way. There is no distinctive lead but I guess its supposed to be more like theme music. The major thing is that it is too repetitive and doesn't really go anywhere. I didn't really get a feel for what the author was trying to achive with this, the track just comes and goes and never really gets anywhere. Try to make the music have a purpose, like its trying to get somewhere. |
Judge: Tumidajewicz ,Przemek Overused chord progression. Good perc, but lacks variation. The song is one idea repeated and repeated and repeated. Are you sure you've chosen the right division? |
Judge: Noel ,Elliott A bit random and repetitive, not overly interesting but clean. |